In my series on using sound composition in the English Language Arts classroom, my last post focused on how to go about collecting the sounds students need to create careful and intentional compositions. The next step after this is, of course, to put those sounds together in meaningful ways. For this, we need sound editing software. Luckily there are lots of excellent, FREE options available to us.
The 3 best (and again, totally free) options I know of and have had success with are:
Garage Band | A proprietary software put out by Apple for use with Apple products.
- It works smoothly with no bugs. I’ve never heard of a problem with Garage Band crashing.
- The user interface is intuitive and easy-to-learn. It won’t take new users long to get comfortable.
- It comes bundled with lots of pre-recorded material such as sound effects and music for students to use as they work. I personally don’t like this because I prefer to have my students go through the process of choosing and finding specific sounds, but the pre-loaded material definitely makes composing with sound a bit easier.
- This is made by and for Apple. It only works on Macs, so this can be limiting depending on what your students are using.
- Sound editing options such as effects and processing options are more limited in Garage Band than in a more complex program like Audacity.
Beautiful Audio Editor | An experimental web-based audio editor for desktop and mobile.
- Beautiful Audio Editor is SUPER easy to use. The interface is simple and intuitive. You can show a student how to drive it in 10 minutes, and they’ll have what they need to complete basic tasks.
- The program is web-based, do you don’t have to download anything. You can download the app if you’d like, or you can just visit the site and work from there.
- It’s still in the beta phase, so it is buggy, particularly on projects that exceed 300MB or around 45 minutes in length.
- It only works with Google Chrome or Mozilla Firefox.
- The simplicity of Beautiful Audio Editor comes at a cost; it is a little limited in what it can do.
Audacity | A free, open-source sound editing software that works on any operating system.
- Audacity has been around since 2000, so it’s not buggy. It’s dependable, and there are LOTS of tutorials out there, as people have been using it successfully for years.
- It is very powerful and can do basically everything. A student who is nervous and hesitant will be able to create basic compositions, but a student with some background in sound editing can really have some fun.
- Audacity is cross-platform. You can use it on any operating system. It will work on Windows, Mac, or Linux, so students can use whatever devices they have available to them without limitation.
- Audacity can be complicated to use. It has a lot of functionality for a free software, but that means that it can be overwhelming to users of all ages who are new to composing with sound. This also means that, in a classroom setting, you have to budget some significant time for training students on how to use it well and confidently.
- Audacity does not come with any pre-recorded material like Garage Band does. So newbies who are looking to play around have to gather all their materials.
- I have read some accounts of Audacity crashing on users, but I personally have never had this happen.
All of these options allow multiple tracks, which helps students play with layering and sound interaction. All of them are free and very reasonable to teach students to use. There are also always new options emerging, so it’s a good idea to pay attention to the tech blogs and top 10 lists out there.
In my opinion, the choice of which software to use comes down to complexity of the project and confidence of the teacher. Beautiful Audio Editor is the simplest, most basic of these options, but it is also the most limited and unreliable. Audacity is the most complicated, but it is also the most powerful. Garage Band seems to strike a balance between the options and may be a good starting place for classrooms that have adequate access to Mac devices.
Ultimately, the absolute best way to make the choice on which editor option is the best for you is to mess around with them! Create some smaller compositions of your own and see which editor makes the most sense to you and most closely meets your assignment needs.